American Idol ......11 left week

[rusty JEDI]

From the AI forum.



A friend of mine recorded all the performances on Tuesday night and then ran them through a pitch corrector in his studio, these were the results....quite surprising:

Bo - 2 notes out of tune (Not surprising, only TWO notes)

Nikko - 4 notes out of tune (Simon was WAY wrong on this one)

Carrie - 5 notes out of tune

Anthony - 5 notes out of tune

Contantine - 5 notes out of tune

Mikalah - 7 notes out of tune (surprise, NOT the most out of tune in the bunch)

Lindsay - 8 notes out of tune

Jessica - 9 notes out of tune

Nadia - 9 notes ut of tune

Vonzell - 9 notes out of tune(not my fav. but I think 9 is a good number on such a hard song to sing in tune)

Scott - 10 notes out of tune

Anwar - 13 notes out of tune (wow, very surprising. according to THIS he was the worst singer on Tuesday night)

So according to technological devices MADE for the sole purpose of determining pitch, and NOT based on someone's opinion, the contestants are ranked, above, from best to worst as far as TUESDAY'S PERFORMANCE. This was just a fun thing to do with some surprising and fun results. With all of the arguments on here as to who is the "best" singer, I just thought I would point out that what it really comes down to is who is your FAVORITE. Because I will BET that SOMEBODY'S favorite is located at or toward the bottom of the list, and that someone's LEAST favorite is located near or AT the top. Just sharing the information. Thought it would be inte


Anwar will from here on out be referred to as Asswar.

rJ

[mybutthurts]

does american idol really have anything to do with internet poker? or is this post just to entertain bored houswives?

[Bytestream]

since you are a newb with only 4 posts, youre ignorance can be excused. If you look to the left side of your internet browser, you will notice a list of forums. The one you are in right now, is the "Internet Gambling" forum, notice there is no reference to poker in the title.

There might be over 10k +EV dollars wagered on American Idol by members of this forum.

Bored and desperate housewives are always welcome btw.

[RollaJ]

[ QUOTE ]
There might be over 10k +EV dollars wagered on American Idol by members of this forum.

[/ QUOTE ]

Ill take the over.

As for the "scientific" study, Im not buying it at all

[GrannyMae]

From the AI forum.

loosely translated:

<font color="green">From an 11 year old girl who made it all up. </font>


Only to be belived by those more tone deaf than her. i'm guessing when she was 10, she was a JPL fan??

[Daliman]

There is a difference between "out of tune" and improvising notes. I don't know what this machine is that was used, but I guarantee you if it listened to "With a little help from my friends" by the beatles, then the Joe Cocker version, it would think Joe Cocker's version was almost completely out of tune. Only a trained ear can tell you when something is truly out of tune, and not merely an improvisation.

That said, Anwar DID miss at lot of notes,(pay close attention when he starts off one of his dirges. Similar to Diana Degarmo last year, he meanders about the song until the payoff notes come, although to a lesser extent.) Bo was flat and uninspriring on a lot of his, and I didn't catch a single off note from Nadia