who played it worse?

[3rdCheckRaise]

I was watching my friend playing party $20 SNG and this hand came up. Who do you think played it worse?
rny:6420051 Level:1 Blinds(10/15) - Monday, October 11, 01:53:42 EDT 2004
Table Table 14437 (Real Money)
Seat 5 is the button
Total number of players : 9
Seat 3: zpyles ( $930 )
Seat 4: DrunkPirate ( $807 )
Seat 5: Sluggo43 ( $770 )
Seat 6: Beachbum27 ( $817 )
Seat 7: pip31 ( $775 )
Seat 8: peberry55 ( $1566 )
Seat 9: klassicd ( $735 )
Seat 10: Jackson5678 ( $840 )
Seat 1: givme1 ( $760 )
Trny:6420051 Level:1
Blinds(10/15)
** Dealing down cards **
Dealt to givme1 [ As Ts ]
peberry55 folds.
klassicd folds.
Jackson5678 folds.
givme1 calls [15].
zpyles folds.
DrunkPirate calls [15].
Sluggo43 folds.
Beachbum27 calls [5].
pip31 raises [50].
givme1 calls [50].
DrunkPirate folds.
Beachbum27 folds.
** Dealing Flop ** [ Kd, 6s, Qh ]
pip31 checks.
givme1 checks.
** Dealing Turn ** [ 4s ]
>You have options at Table 13812 Table!.
pip31 bets [100].
givme1 raises [350].
>You have options at Table 13812 Table!.
pip31 calls [250].
** Dealing River ** [ 2s ]
pip31 bets [100].
givme1 raises [300].
pip31 calls [200].
givme1 shows [ As, Ts ] a flush, ace high.
pip31 doesn't show [ Qc, Kc ] two pairs, kings and queens.
givme1 wins 1460 chips from the main pot with a flush, ace high.

[Bigwig]

giveme1.

[GingerD]

Both awful play, when pip1 was reraised on the turn, he should have gone all in.

[ChrisV]

givme1. The other guy was a bit retarded to not reraise allin on the turn, but givme1 made two major errors - (1) calling preflop, which is going to lead to wailing and gnashing of teeth in the event he flops a pair rather than backdooring a flush, and (2) the raise on the turn, which is just horrible. From the other guy's play so far, he has either rubbish or a huge hand. If he has rubbish you'll find out on the river and can pick the pot up then. If he has a huge hand you have to call and try and crack him. If he'd been less stupid he'd have reraised allin and you'd be in a world of hurt.

[rachelwxm]

Comparing to people go all in with 4flush or str4 on party poker these days, your friend is not that bad.
If he can make a turn reraise, I am sure limping PF is fine with him.
[img]/images/graemlins/cool.gif[/img]