Is the Rounders \"Collecter\'s Edition\" DVD any good?
 

I thought the movie itself was entertaining enough to rewatch once in a while, but is the extra stuff on the DVD any good? I'm talking about the commentary from several poker pros and other non-movie poker material on the DVD. For anyone who has the DVD, is it worth it?

Re: Is the Rounders \"Collecter\'s Edition\" DVD any good?
 

If you're the kind of person who likes listening to director's commentaries, you'll probably like the collector's edition.

The commentaries are entertaining (when compared to other commentaries). Sklansky makes an appearance in one of the extra clips about being a professional gambler too.

Other than that, the extras are pretty worthless. If you don't already own Rounder's, it's probably better to get the collector's addition, but I'd never buy the movie again just for the extras.

Re: Is the Rounders \"Collecter\'s Edition\" DVD any good?
 

i like the players' commentary. phil is phil obv and tries to be the commentary captain, but others pick on him and correct him as necessary. moneymaker kees it real. chan is funny, but ferguson barely talks. . . worth owning imo

Re: Is the Rounders \"Collecter\'s Edition\" DVD any good?
 

I agree with randomstumble, if I had already owned the 1st edition the collectors edition would not have seemed worth it. If you do not own the 1st edition though, the extras in the collectors are entertaining, and interesting.

Re: Is the Rounders \"Collecter\'s Edition\" DVD any good?
 

Phil Helmuth almost ruins the player commentary for me. This guy was more annoying just talking about himself than anything he does while playing. Every chance he gets, he relates something to himiself. If you enjoy the movie, I would get it though.