MVPs and Cy Young

[andyfox]

If they asked me to vote today, I'd vote:

AL MVP
1) A-Rod
2) Ortiz
3) Hafner
4) Vlad
5) Teixeira
6) Manny
7) Sheffield
8) Young
9) Konerko
10) Jeter

NL MVP
1) Lee
2) Pujols
3) Jones
4) Cabrera
5) Delgado
6) Ensberg
7) B. Giles
8) Willis
9) Carpenter
10)Cordero

AL Cy Young
1) Rivera
2) Colon
3) Santana

NL Cy Young
1) Willis
2) Carpenter
3) Cordero

[Mvcode3]

good thing you dont get to vote

[Paluka]

Andy aren't you giving Brian Roberts the screwjob here?

[andyfox]

[img]/images/graemlins/smile.gif[/img]

You're probably right.

[nothumb]

Hafner has no business ahead of Vlad, Manny, and probably Texeira and Sheff. Though I like him a lot.

Lee is third in NL MVP this year, and I think Pujols deserves it.

Rivera was only a Cy Young if he saved everything from June on IMHO, although nobody else leaps out at me. Hell, I don't care.

Willis I really like, I wouldn't mind seeing him win.

NT

[andyfox]

I thought he was the MVP of the league the first half (or sixty games or so). Yeah, he might well be included. Maybe Peralta too.

[andyfox]

AL Cy Young is a tough one. Colon didn't help himself any today.

[Mvcode3]

no way roberts can ben in the top 10. The o's suck and he fell off big time.

[Paluka]

[ QUOTE ]
I thought he was the MVP of the league the first half (or sixty games or so). Yeah, he might well be included. Maybe Peralta too.

[/ QUOTE ]

He plays what clearly seems to be the weakest position in the league. The Sox and Yankees can't find a decent 2b between them.

[Mvcode3]

[ QUOTE ]
Hafner has no business ahead of Vlad, Manny, and probably Texeira and Sheff. Though I like him a lot.
NT

[/ QUOTE ]

Hafner has led the Indians to a comback, and put up big numbers playing a short season, Plus he doesnt have guys like Michael young and Ortiz