A problem with some religous views

[chezlaw]

Following on from Rejecting God and the discussion with NotReady, this is why I believe some religous views must be mistaken.

consider the statement:

"we are all guilty of sins, those who believe can get redemption and those who don't believe have no chance of redemption and will be punished"

The religons I have a problem with claim that this statement (or something similar) is true.

My moral sense tells me that a god who enforces this view is morally repugnant.

So either I am being deceived by my feelings of right and wrong, god isn't good, or that religous view is mistaken.


There's more but it all relies on this simple argument. Any flaw in the logic?


chez