The 6th Harry Potter book (yea...that spoiler)

[splashpot]

Call me gay for reading Harry Potter, I don't care. The new movie got me thinking about the book I read over the summer. For those who have read it, do you think there is any possibility that Snape is still good? My theory is that Dumbledore made Snape promise to kill him if certain circumstances arose. Dumbledore supposedly had a very good reason to trust Snape. It seems too hard to believe that Dumbledore was wrong about him.

[Dynasty]

There's just enough evidence in the books to make this common theory valid.

[irishpint]

duh snape is good. its a kids book. where were you when this was discussed so long ago? this isn't your theory...this is everyone's!

I definately think that something is up. What got me thinking is that Dumbledore swore that Snape could be trusted, and immediately when Dumbledore encounters Snape at the end of the book he's begging for mercy. Why the sudden switch? It's gotta be a trick to fool Malfoy into a false sense of security. Seemed fishy to me. I've considered the possibility that Snape aggred to kill Dumbledore but I'd rather it be the case that Dumbledore is still alive. The theory does make sense. Snape need to prove his allegiance to Voldermort and how better than to kill Dumbledore. We shall see how things unfold.

p.s. Call me gay too. The books are good.

[stabn]

[ QUOTE ]
duh snape is good. its a kids book. where were you when this was discussed so long ago? this isn't your theory...this is everyone's!

[/ QUOTE ]

The bolded is [censored] reasoning in a series that has killed sirius/dumbledore/cedric etc.

[splashpot]

[ QUOTE ]
duh snape is good. its a kids book. where were you when this was discussed so long ago? this isn't your theory...this is everyone's!

[/ QUOTE ]
Well none of my friends believe it. And I think it was pretty clear that Dumbledore is dead. I think it would be lame to bring him back.

[stabn]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
duh snape is good. its a kids book. where were you when this was discussed so long ago? this isn't your theory...this is everyone's!

[/ QUOTE ]
Well none of my friends believe it. And I think it was pretty clear that Dumbledore is dead. I think it would be lame to bring him back.

[/ QUOTE ]

Snape being good and dumbledore being alive are two totally different issues though. The common blief is that snape==good and dumbledore==dead.

[MelK]

Snape is Harry's real father.

You heard it here first.

[wdeadwyler]

Two things:
If you notice the most recent movie, when Harry is reliving Dumbledore's memories, Igor (who is snitching to get out of prison) remarks that Snape is "forever loyal to Voldemart". I think this is foreshadowing of his betrayal, and do not believe Snape is good.

Secondly, and I may or may not receive [censored] for this, but Emma Watson is jailbait.

[NYplayer]

http://www.dumbledoreisnotdead.com/