possible fantasy trade

[Victor]

league is 1 qb, 2rb, 2wr etc.
here is my current team:

tom brady
kurt warner

edge
michael anderson
carnell williams
larry johnson
najeh davenport

chad johnson
randy moss
rod smith

i have been offered peyton manning for brady and carnell.

my opponents team basically sucks.

it is somewhat important that the manning guy has also offered manning to someone else for carson palmer and thomas jones.

[phillydilly]

i dont think i could pull the trigger here.
While cadillac has been hot, and peyton cold, and these could easily change.

i like
brady
edge
cadillac
better than
peyton
edge
anderson

[nyc999]

I think you can get more for Carnell and Brady. While everyone fears Carnell will slow down, he has shown no signs so far. I also don't like having several players from the same offense (i.e. Edge and Manning) - what happens when they play a tough defensive squad?

[brettbrettr]

I see no reason to make this trade. You're team is excellent. With those RBs and those WRs Brady is easily enough QB.

[Soul Daddy]

[ QUOTE ]
I see no reason to make this trade. You're team is excellent. With those RBs and those WRs Brady is easily enough QB.

[/ QUOTE ]
Echo. This trade would not make your team better. You'd be putting way too much stock in Mike Anderson.

[Clarkmeister]

[ QUOTE ]
I see no reason to make this trade.

[/ QUOTE ]

[fingokra]

Why not counter with Brady and Johnson or Brady and Anderson?

[Victor]

[ QUOTE ]
Why not counter with Brady and Johnson or Brady and Anderson?

[/ QUOTE ]

that was my initial offer. this was his counter.

[brettbrettr]

I would really be happy to stand pat here.

[fingokra]

Ahh, okay didn't know that. Turn him down and reoffer, reoffer trying to make it a three player deal with Smith or someone else, or just turn him down. Gee that just about covers everthing,lol