Wrong player declared the winner?

[TxSteve]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]

Just as a guess, was the ace of clubs on the board? If it was in your hand, then you obviously have the nuts.

[/ QUOTE ]


unless he lost to a straight-flush (or mis-read his hand as was also mentioned)

[/ QUOTE ]

The other player can't have an ace high straight flush. The OP mentioned the other player had an ace high flush.

Of course, misreading the hand is likely.

[/ QUOTE ]

fyp

I admit that I may be wrong. I will try again to find the hand replay, but I couldn't find it before. I am convinced I had the A of clubs and the other guy won with a flush A high. The A was in my hand, but I will admit I had a senior moment if I can see the replay. That would be a hell of a misread.

[bluefeet]

I'm guessing MicroBob is correct. He had a straight-flush...quite possible with four on the board.

[MicroBob]

i think you need to leave the table to access the hand-replayer.


i think it only keeps your last 20 hands...so if you've been playing all this time then it may already be gone (unless it's changed...which is possible)

Wait just a second. I read somewhere that the winner's hand is always revealed. Why is he guessing what the other guy had?

[MicroBob]

oh yeah.

I think a couple years ago I could have SWORN that Pacific gave the pot to my opponent when I should have gotten it.

By the time I figured out how to use the hand-replayer though it was gone so I couldn't see what happened.

GrannyMae confirmed that it was perhaps possible.
Of course, I also conceded that it was probably just my own error.
The showdowns and pot-shoves happen fairly quickly on that site so it's kind of hard to see what's going on.


On Pacific I don't think it's 100% impossible for this to have happened.
but I do think it's more likely that the player had the Ace of Spades and King of Clubs but somehow got them mixed-up in his head.

I was so amazed that the chips went to the other player, then the hand was gone. All I had was the dealer chat. It happened too fast. If they only hold the last 20 hands in replay, it is too late. Maybe I made a mistake, maybe not. At least it didn't break me.

[pecto]

were u playing omaha??

No, hold 'em

Boy, do I feel like a dummy. I found the replay and the A was on the table. My opponent had a higher club kicker. I would have probably played it the same in any case. THanks for the feedback, all.