Which type of player will do better in the average $100 NL game

[guns4show]

1. A smart, pretty tight and aggressive player.

2. A smart, loose and very aggressive player.


Which type of player is more sucessful usually? I realize that it is much easier to be the tight player, but I also realize that they can be just as sucessful. In your opinion, which has a better shot at suceeding at the $100 NL level.