The Top 10 NFL QBs

[MarkL444]

[ QUOTE ]
Joey Harrington (He's just so calm in the pocket, flawless decision making, etc, etc)

[/ QUOTE ]

dont ever say this to a lions fan [img]/images/graemlins/mad.gif[/img] [img]/images/graemlins/mad.gif[/img] [img]/images/graemlins/mad.gif[/img] [img]/images/graemlins/mad.gif[/img] [img]/images/graemlins/mad.gif[/img] [img]/images/graemlins/mad.gif[/img] [img]/images/graemlins/mad.gif[/img]

[yoadrians]

-Manning
-McNabb
-Brady
-Favre
-Vick
-Brees
-Culpepper
-Palmer
-Bulger
-E. Manning???

I know Favre is off some people's lists, but I think he's still top 10. Christ, give the guy his line and J. Walker back, for goodness sakes.

[VarlosZ]

1. Manning
2. Brady
3. McNabb
4. Culpepper
5. Brees
6. Green
7. Hasselbeck
8. Palmer
9. Bulger
10. Favre

Vick is poor passer, so no go. Roethlisberger isn't asked to do very much. Delhomme throws too many INTs.

Can't believe people are mentioning Eli -- he was terrible last year. He's certainly been better this season, but he's faced weak pass defenses. See me again at the end of the year if he keeps it up.

[Roybert]

[ QUOTE ]


Can't believe people are mentioning Eli -- he was terrible in 4 games last year, average in 1 more and great in 2 .

[/ QUOTE ]

FYP

[VarlosZ]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]


Can't believe people are mentioning Eli -- he was terrible in 4 games last year, average in 1 more and great in 2 .

[/ QUOTE ]

FYP

[/ QUOTE ]

Eli wasn't "great" in any games last year, but whatever. Roll all those performances together, and what do you get?

Comp%: 48.2 -- YPA: 5.3 -- TD/INT: 6/9 -- QBrat: 55.4

That was easily among the very worst in the league last year, hence "terrible." I'm a Giants fan, so I'm pulling for him real hard, and he's definitely got my hopes up this season. Nonetheless, his schedule this year has been as easy as last year's was difficult, so putting him anywhere near a Top 10 list seems ridiculous. The jury's still out.

[maxsick]

1) Peyton Manning
2) Donovan McNabb
3) Tom Brady
4) Trent Green
5) Marc Bulger
6) Daunte Culpepper
7) Drew Brees
8) Jake Delhomme
9) Matt Hasselbeck
10) Carson Palmer

Runners-up (in vague order): Vick, Favre, Big Ben, Leftwich, McNair, E. Manning, Collins, Bledsoe, Dilfer, Griese.

[Clarkmeister]

I'd put them in groups.

Group A - Guys you'd kill to have on your team.
Group B - Guys you are happy with.
Group C - Guys you feel pretty ok about. Nothing special but they are definitely competant starters not holding the team back.
Group D - Guys who have their moments, but frankly, you'd rather see someone else.
Group F - Guys who need immediate replacement.

I think Group A basically includes two players - Brady and Manning.

Group B is much bigger.

Group C is very large. QB play in the NFL isn't that bad right now.

Group D basically is your journeyman rent-a-QB's. Ferrotte, Dilfer, Griese. You get the ideal.

Group F is the obvious. Harrington and the like.

[MonkeeMan]

There are 4 teams in the league who wouldn't trade their QB for anyone else.

1a. Brady
1b. P. Manning
1c. McNabb
1d. Vick

There are others that their respective teams really like alot, but would part with for one of those 4.

No particular order:
Leftwich
Palmer
E. Manning
Roethlisberger
Culpepper (well they used to)
Delhomme

The rest would be traded in a heartbeat except Farve for obvious reasons.

[JTrout]

[ QUOTE ]
There are 4 teams in the league who wouldn't trade their QB for anyone else.

1a. Brady
1b. P. Manning
1c. McNabb
1d. Vick

There are others that their respective teams really like alot, but would part with for one of those 4.

No particular order:
Leftwich
Palmer
E. Manning
Roethlisberger
Culpepper (well they used to)
Delhomme

The rest would be traded in a heartbeat except Farve for obvious reasons.

[/ QUOTE ]

[Bulldog]

[ QUOTE ]
There are 4 teams in the league who wouldn't trade their QB for anyone else.

1a. Brady
1b. P. Manning
1c. McNabb
1d. Vick



[/ QUOTE ]

JMJ would trade Vick for Manning in a heartbeat.