Slow Play? #1 (PLO8)

[beset7]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
any suggestions

[/ QUOTE ]

For starters, delete any thread where somebody is trying to figure out the winning low hand.

[/ QUOTE ]

that's a start thanks. good idea.

[/ QUOTE ]

Consider a "Play a Hand with the Masters" that the MTT forum is doing. It's gotten great reviews.

-g

[/ QUOTE ]

Would you want to start something like that? If you put together the posts I'll sticky a guide and links to the post on each street. When I play o8 its mostly live mid-limit stuff and not very interesting. I think you or WM could come up with a good hand.

And no thanks on the porn wm but that's a nice thought.

[niwotyalpi]

Here are the problems with the forum, in no particular order:

1. You have people posting advice who have no business giving advice. I mean some of these clowns post advice that is so bad it makes me want to vomit.

2. You have newbs posting hands and then when some of the better posters point out how badly they played the hand, the original poster gets pissed and starts insulting the people who are trying to help. In turn the good posters just refuse to give advice on here anymore, they prefer to use sarcastic one liners, which I find amusing FWIW.

I think the only way to clean this forum up is that when someone posts bad advice on multiple occasions, they should be warned not to post advice and if they continue to do so just [censored] Ban them. JMO

[beset7]

[ QUOTE ]
1. You have people posting advice who have no business giving advice. I mean some of these clowns post advice that is so bad it makes me want to vomit.


[/ QUOTE ]

I think one of the disadvantages we have is we don't have a micro, small, high-limit breakdown. In the micro-limit HE forums, for example, people just blindly post bad advice--it's expected of them. Then, the more knowledgeable posters who are maybe just a bit ahead of them in the learning process correct them about the stupid stuff they say and everybody learns from it (supposedly). Conversely, in the mid/high forums, a higher standard is expected and its preferable that people lurk if they are FOS. We don't have that luxury. This makes it tough to delete posts with bad content or noobish thinking.

[ QUOTE ]
2. You have newbs posting hands and then when some of the better posters point out how badly they played the hand, the original poster gets pissed and starts insulting the people who are trying to help. In turn the good posters just refuse to give advice on here anymore, they prefer to use sarcastic one liners, which I find amusing FWIW.

[/ QUOTE ]

This always annoys me. Just a couple weeks ago I spent a substantial amount of time responding to some posts in the PLO forum only to get flamed by the original poster because he didn't like the fact he had totally bumbled up the hand. Definitely a problem and I'll lock threads when this happens.

[ QUOTE ]
I think the only way to clean this forum up is that when someone posts bad advice on multiple occasions, they should be warned not to post advice and if they continue to do so just [censored] Ban them. JMO

[/ QUOTE ]

I think this is problematic. I think a better rule of thumb might be that people shouldn't post with regards to stakes they either (a) don't play (b) don't have the requisite knowledge to play (i'm thinking of guys like Buzz who play 3/6 or whatever but probably understand limit O8 better then a lot of the guys in the 75/150). If somebody is persistently posting with regards to hands they aren't qualified to discuss, I could see warning them.

But if a newb wants to respond to every PLO25 post as a learning exercise I don't see why I'd want to discourage that.

Also, I want to remind everyone that at the bottom of each post there is a button that will notify me by e-mail (I carry a Crackberry [for other reasons obviously] so I'll get it right away) to come check out the post. This isn't only for spam. If you think a post is ridiculuous, painfully low content, out-of-line, etc, please just click the notify moderator button. I'll check it out and if I agree I'll do something. If not, I'll leave it, no harm no foul.

[Big Dave D]

Can we have a Wintermute annoying the feck out of me button added too? :-)

How about a Ribbo targetting mechanism...I'm sure Captain America would find WMD in Warrington.

gl

dd

[Burdzthewurd]

I'd like to see more PLO8 tournament hands posted, maybe use that for the "Hand with the Masters" segment once in awhile? I can't think off the top of my head anyone but myself that posts MTT and SNG PLO8 hands, I'd think someone else out there plays these more often than I.

[beset7]

[ QUOTE ]
Can we have a Wintermute annoying the feck out of me button added too? :-)

How about a Ribbo targetting mechanism...I'm sure Captain America would find WMD in Warrington.

gl

dd

[/ QUOTE ]

[img]/images/graemlins/laugh.gif[/img]

[beset7]

I have two other ideas from other forums I read:

(1) A weekly, or maybe in the case of this forum monthly, digest of the most worthwhile threads posted during previous week/month. If a regular poster is interested in doing this and can be consistent about it for a while just let me know and I'll sticky the post once you've gone through the last month and found the best 5-10 threads. Whoever does this may want break the digest up into limit and pot-limit posts. This practice is good not only because it can help take care of FAQs but it also revives good threads that people may have overlooked. Example of a Digest.

(2) A "How Good is your O8" type post. In the small stakes NLHE forum a poster puts a hand together and posts it with a poll for each street. It's interesting to see what the majority of people would do on each street and it often provokes some good discussion. No need to volunteer for this one just do it and I'll make it a sticky till it burns out. Example.

[gergery]

[ QUOTE ]
Can we have a Wintermute annoying the feck out of me button added too? :-)

How about a Ribbo targetting mechanism...I'm sure Captain America would find WMD in Warrington.

gl

dd

[/ QUOTE ]

I wouldn’t mind invading Warrington, but the stench might be overpowering

Can we wear gas masks?