edgerrin james for torry holt? straight up trade

[unlucky513]

do you make this trade?
this would leave me with willis mcgahee, stephen davis, thomas jones and tatum bell at RB.

as for WR's, right now i have mccardell, jimmy smith, and amani toomer.

i think this is a good trade for me, anyone disagree?

[Dynasty]

James is a much better player. You should be getting more for him.

[noggindoc]

[ QUOTE ]
do you make this trade?
this would leave me with willis mcgahee, stephen davis, thomas jones and tatum bell at RB.

as for WR's, right now i have mccardell, jimmy smith, and amani toomer.

i think this is a good trade for me, anyone disagree?

[/ QUOTE ]

you can get a WR better than Holt for James I'd imagine

[lastchance]

Edge is a RB. Therefore, he's more valuable than Holt most of the time.

If you start 2 RB's and 3 WR's, I think you could make this trade, but you'd probably be asking for Moss or Owens instead. Otherwise, I'd reject it very, very quickly.

[tech]

Keep James. Trade Davis or Jones for Holt. Package somebody else with it if you have to.

[Victor]

edge for holt straight is straight up retarded.

[Punker]

It would improve your team, yes, but other posters are right: you can get much more for Edge.

[Clarkmeister]

I'll dissent and say I'd do it.

[MarkL444]

stay put, you have good depth. im not super confident and davis and jones

[Clarkmeister]

[ QUOTE ]
Trade Davis or Jones for Holt. Package somebody else with it if you have to.

[/ QUOTE ]

Not happening.