Advice on a baseball keeper league. Pick 5 to keep.

[z32fanatic]

I'm in a keeper league and need to keep 5 guys from my team. Who would you guys keep?
I. Rodriguez
Vidro
ARod
Renteria
Nomar
Mag. Ordonez
Podsednik
Francoeur
Soriano
Pettitte
Wood
Schilling
Hampton

The league is a typical 5x5 rotisserie league. I was planning on keeping ARod, Soriano, Nomar, Podsednik (you can basically win SBs with him alone), and Pudge. The main one I'm concerned about is Pudge. Hampton, Schilling and Wood are all really questionable and probably not worth keeping. I might be willing to jump on the Francoeur train over Pudge. Any advice from baseball fans out there?

[battschr]

ARod, Soriano, Pods for sure....other than that I think it's a crapshoot here....I'd keep Pudge and one of your 2 SS.

[hobbsmann]

[ QUOTE ]
ARod, Soriano, Pods for sure....other than that I think it's a crapshoot here....I'd keep Pudge and one of your 2 SS.

[/ QUOTE ]

These are my thoughts as well.

[nyc999]

A-Rod, Soriano, I-Rod, Petitte and Podsednik. Francouer is coming down to earth. But man, you have a seriously injury-prone squad.

[Jim Kuhn]

Irod is an old 34. Very much downside for catchers. I would keep Arod, Soriano, Pods, Francoeur and Renteria.

Thank you,

Jim Kuhn
Catfish4u
[img]/images/graemlins/spade.gif[/img] [img]/images/graemlins/diamond.gif[/img] [img]/images/graemlins/club.gif[/img] [img]/images/graemlins/heart.gif[/img]

[New001]

A. Rodriguez, Soriano, Podsednik, Pettite, and flip a coin for the last one?

[bugstud]

[ QUOTE ]
I'm in a keeper league and need to keep 5 guys from my team. Who would you guys keep?
I. Rodriguez
Vidro
ARod
Renteria
Nomar
Mag. Ordonez
Podsednik
Francoeur
Soriano
Pettitte
Wood
Schilling
Hampton

The league is a typical 5x5 rotisserie league. I was planning on keeping ARod, Soriano, Nomar, Podsednik (you can basically win SBs with him alone), and Pudge. The main one I'm concerned about is Pudge. Hampton, Schilling and Wood are all really questionable and probably not worth keeping. I might be willing to jump on the Francoeur train over Pudge. Any advice from baseball fans out there?

[/ QUOTE ].

ok, locks - ARod, Soriano
good ideas - Pods (vomit)
and the rest...I go with nomar and mags and hope for 2 full seasons. I'd try to deal and get some talent on the team.

[MarkL444]

my advice as an avid tigers follower is to keep mags over pudge.

but in all honesty, cant you work a trade? maybe upgrade to a better SS?

[pokerdirty]

can you trade players for picks? maybe you can sucker someone in to trading one of your pitchers for a 2nd/3rd round pick