Sex with friends' sisters. Acceptable?

[HopeydaFish]

A friend of mine banged his best friend's sister for 3 years without the best friend finding out about it. He was quite convinced that his sister hated the guy in question, and was never suspicious. It's been 10+ years since this all went down, and he's still none the wiser.

[samjjones]

[ QUOTE ]
A friend of mine banged his best friend's sister for 3 years without the best friend finding out about it. He was quite convinced that his sister hated the guy in question, and was never suspicious. It's been 10+ years since this all went down, and he's still none the wiser.

[/ QUOTE ]
Yes, this is pretty much the exact situation I describe above. What is my play?

[HopeydaFish]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
A friend of mine banged his best friend's sister for 3 years without the best friend finding out about it. He was quite convinced that his sister hated the guy in question, and was never suspicious. It's been 10+ years since this all went down, and he's still none the wiser.

[/ QUOTE ]
Yes, this is pretty much the exact situation I describe above. What is my play?

[/ QUOTE ]

It depends on all sorts of factors:

1) How much do you want to stay friends with these people?
2) Will broaching the subject potentially end any friendships?
3) Does the guy who banged the sister have any "secrets" that he knows about you that he could spill in retaliation?
4) Is it possible that your friend will "shoot the messenger" in that he'll blame you for not telling him about the banging sooner?
5) Do you have any animosity towards the guy who banged the sister?

In my case, I never told my friend that the guy was banging his sister because I knew that my friend would have been upset with me for keeping the information from him for so long. I also knew that this information would devastate my friend and would hurt his relationship with his sister. Finally, the guy who banged the sister had some dirt on me and I knew that he'd find a way to retaliate.

In the end, I decided that staying out of it was the best solution. Telling my friend that his little sister was getting [censored] regularly by his best friend would have caused a massive [censored]-storm that I would have been the centre of. I didn't need the drama in my life.

[djoyce003]

I think in general you have a better shot at the girl friends sister...a guy friend is probably more protective and would get pissed if you banged his little sister...just a guess here.

[jackdaniels]

I was 15 years old and hanging out at my friends house. His parents were away in London and only he and his sister (19) were home. We are watching something on tv with him is sitting on the armchair and she and I sharing the loveseat ( <- foreshadowing here!). Anyway, it's a bit cold at his place so she brings out a blanket and asks if I wanna share. "Sure" I say. After we cover up I suddenly feel her hand slowly creeping across my thigh and ending up right in my crotch. As she is slowly massaging my meat through my jeans, her brother becomes a bit nervous about the whole situation and tries to get me to leave the room with him and go play some pool or something. I wasn’t going anywhere! Now, he obviously knows something is going on and decides the only way to diffuse the situation is by asking me to leave. BIG mistake! I made no fuss when he asked me to leave his house, I simply stood up (not even bothering to cover up my boner), walked to the door and let him close it behind me. As soon as the door shut, I turned around and rang the doorbell. When he opened it again and asked me if I forgot something I coolly replied: “No, I’m not here to see you, I’m here to visit Michelle”. He turned a red color I have only seen in cartoons and started stammering. I quickly nodded to her and she came to the door and escorted me to her room. I lost my virginity that night and he had to suffer on the other side of her door knowing exactly what was going on. Needless to say, I did not speak with the guy for about 2 years after that incident, but we reconciled and became friends again after that.

So is banging your friend’s sister a good idea? I can’t answer that question. But I know that if I had to do it all over again, there is no doubt in my mind that I wouldn’t change a thing.

[Yeti]

That is a cool story. If true.

[M0n3y0nf1r3]

[ QUOTE ]
When he opened it again and asked me if I forgot something I coolly replied: “No, I’m not here to see you, I’m here to visit Michelle”.

[/ QUOTE ]
If any of my friends wanted to run this I would punch them in the face... Or run kitchen knife stabs [img]/images/graemlins/laugh.gif[/img] .

[PokerFink]

[ QUOTE ]
When he opened it again and asked me if I forgot something I coolly replied: “No, I’m not here to see you, I’m here to visit Michelle”.

[/ QUOTE ]

Thats very money. I'm surprised you guys became friends again.

[jackdaniels]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
When he opened it again and asked me if I forgot something I coolly replied: “No, I’m not here to see you, I’m here to visit Michelle”.

[/ QUOTE ]

Thats very money. I'm surprised you guys became friends again.

[/ QUOTE ]

Yeah, surprisingly, we became friends because he came back from summer vacation and started talking to others in class how he played this cool game called "Dungeons and Dragons" all summer. Being a part time geek myself I couldn't hold back and simply started asking questions. When he answered them, I knew he had "cooled off". I asked if I could play and he said it would be cool. Thinking back now, it must have been less than 2 years that we didn't speak since I distincly remember playing D&D with him when I was 16 and change, so maybe we didn't speak for a year, a year and a half.

How I clearly remember losing my virginity to my friend's sister. We were 13 and drunk, rutting in the leaves under some bushes behind her house like a couple of sweaty little animals. Good times!