|
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Re: ALL Forum Splitting Comments/Suggestions Go here!
I said some of this in another post, but:
1. I think that allowing players to self-select "Advanced" status would work. No snubs since nobody is kept out, and I think that most players have a pretty realistic view of themselves. Honestly, how many $5-20 players like me would have the chutzpa to say, "Hey, I'm one of the most insightful posters here." 2. Sort of a variant on the "Play a hand with the Masters." Have a forum where only advanced players can make the origial post, but anyone can reply. That cuts out a lot of the "Should I fold AA pre-flop?" stuff, but still allows people like me to be involved. Just my my two cents. Sam |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Re: ALL Forum Splitting Comments/Suggestions Go here!
[ QUOTE ]
I said some of this in another post, but: 1. I think that allowing players to self-select "Advanced" status would work. No snubs since nobody is kept out, and I think that most players have a pretty realistic view of themselves. Honestly, how many $5-20 players like me would have the chutzpa to say, "Hey, I'm one of the most insightful posters here." 2. Sort of a variant on the "Play a hand with the Masters." Have a forum where only advanced players can make the origial post, but anyone can reply. That cuts out a lot of the "Should I fold AA pre-flop?" stuff, but still allows people like me to be involved. Just my my two cents. Sam [/ QUOTE ] I think self selection makes the most sense. A lot of times the elementary questions get little response or sarcastic replies from me or others. So I think most people would post the elementary questions in the right forum. I don't think a cutoff by buyin is appropriate. There is not that high a correlation of buyin to level of question. Also how do you compare buyins of a $120 live tournament, a $10 rebuy, a $25 turbo 2-table tournament etc. |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Re: ALL Forum Splitting Comments/Suggestions Go here!
[ QUOTE ]
1. I think that allowing players to self-select "Advanced" status would work. No snubs since nobody is kept out, and I think that most players have a pretty realistic view of themselves. Honestly, how many $5-20 players like me would have the chutzpa to say, "Hey, I'm one of the most insightful posters here." [/ QUOTE ] Even when you divide forums by stakes, people jump forums regularly. Regulating forums by self-assessed skill just won't work. |
#4
|
|||
|
|||
Re: ALL Forum Splitting Comments/Suggestions Go here!
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ] 1. I think that allowing players to self-select "Advanced" status would work. No snubs since nobody is kept out, and I think that most players have a pretty realistic view of themselves. Honestly, how many $5-20 players like me would have the chutzpa to say, "Hey, I'm one of the most insightful posters here." [/ QUOTE ] Even when you divide forums by stakes, people jump forums regularly. Regulating forums by self-assessed skill just won't work. [/ QUOTE ] I believe the suggestion was to 'block' others from access to that elite forum. This wouldnt be good either obviously. ~Justin |
|
|