Duncan or Garnett who you got?

[arod15]

Me and my friend argued for hours about this. I say I take Duncan. Although he is probably the most boring superstar in the league, he is a proven winner. Garnnet has yet in my oppinion lived up to his potential. He is great but can be better, i pick Duncan as over him anyday. Thoughts?

[Clarkmeister]

Fantasy Basketball = Garnett in a landslide

Real Basketball = Duncan

[BadBoyBenny]

Duncan. This would have been better as a poll.

[WC64]

[ QUOTE ]
Fantasy Basketball = Garnett in a landslide

Real Basketball = Duncan

[/ QUOTE ]

I agree

[Hornacek]

LeBron?

Here's how I'd rank the top 5 NBA Playaz:
LeBron
Duncan
KG
The Diggler
Shaq

I'm refusing to put Wade on here because I'm in the minority that his rep and his stats are getting help big time from Shaq's presence. Also, if for some reason your uniform looks exactly like the uniform of the German National Team, Dirk goes up to #2.

Edit: Amare ('04-'05 version) would have ranked #4 ahead of Dirk, but since no one knows how his surgery is going to turn out...

Tough choice, but I go with Garnett. I know Duncan is great but he's also had some great help along the way. Garnett has yet to have a good player beside him. If you pick him and can actually build around him I think he is the better choice.

[JcTc]

[ QUOTE ]
Garnett has yet to have a good player beside him.

[/ QUOTE ]

A few years ago, Cassell, Spree, and Wally were a pretty good supporting cast.

[Brad22]

Duncan has had more success b/c he has better teammates and better coaches - nothing to do with leadership.

Garnett is a better passer, FT shooter, outside shooter, and rebounder.

Duncan is a step up defensively.

About even really.

[TheGame1020]

Duncan cause he hits the big shot. Garnett doesn't make those clutch game winners like TD.

[Hornacek]

Just like his 4th quarter disappearing act in games 3-6 of the NBA Finals this past year, huh?

I'm STILL wondering how Ginobili and/or Horry didn't get the Finals MVP over TD.