Who is your favorite character actor?

[ClassicBob]

Until about 2 years ago, the correct answer by a mile was Paul Giamatti. But now he has finally reached star status that he was deserving for a long time.

Does Philip Seymour Hoffman count, or is he too famous now as well?

Agreed on Giamatti. PSH has to be considered a star now, but another great nomination. Same with Pantaliano. That's what makes this tough, I'm looking for people who were great but never got to make that leap.

Gary