Interesting No Limit Question

[TRBNGR]

My choice is D.

[37offsuit]

D

[JFB37]

Does the order in which the cards came affect anyone's thinking? In my mind, there is a difference between the two diamonds having come on the flop and the second diamond having come off on the turn.

[jwvdcw]

[ QUOTE ]
Does the order in which the cards came affect anyone's thinking? In my mind, there is a difference between the two diamonds having come on the flop and the second diamond having come off on the turn.

[/ QUOTE ]

Well that would definitely affect what you think each opponent has(you would look at how they bet and when), but since DS has told us what each opponent has, that becomes less important. However, it is a bit important in order to determine if our opponent's put the other opponent on the same hand as we do.

[cepstrum]

D.

[Wayfare]

If they are good players, then the answer is definately C: raise the minimum.

Anyone who said fold or call either hasn't read the post or in Sklansky's words "Deserves to lose."

[binions]

This is similar to Omaha8, where you have the A2 nut low with no high hand and feel you are tied for low, and there is a player who has high locked up.

Except you don't split half the pot if a diamond hits.

[Squirrel]

Still no one has agreed with me, but I'm sticking to my guns.

I can't even imagine putting another chip into this pot.

I would be willing to bet if you asked this question to good PL Omaha players, the responses would be very different.

[Wayfare]

You realize you'll have the nuts on the river like 85% of the time here right?

You realize there is another player behind you ALSO with the nuts. If you re-open the betting by min raising, what do you think the other good player is going to do?

Squirrel, you are ridiciulously wrong.

[Squirrel]

You're getting close to what I believe is the proper reasoning.