Child Rape vs. Child Murder

[bernie]

[ QUOTE ]
(when you factor in the unlubed violence that the rapist is going to suffer).


[/ QUOTE ]

You can't really compare being raped by your own parent to being raped in prison. On the one hand, one is in a postion of great trust and expectation of being protected by the person from the 'bad' people. When that person 'is' the bad person.

In prison, you don't have this expectation. The kid will be screwed up mentally much, much longer than the guy in prison will ever be.

[ QUOTE ]
Regarding the question of him living on my street and watching my kids--the answer would have been NFW even if he had never committed these crimes

[/ QUOTE ]

I was asking specifically in regards to him being a sex offender. Put it this way, would you like any sex offender, and a child sex offender at that, after serving 16.5 years to be living on your block? If not, where do you expect them to live? Is it ok if it's on someone else's block? I ask this because this is one main reason I think they ought to be in jail for the rest of their lives, or better yet, executed. I don't believe sex offenders, much less adult sex offenders of children are reformable.

b

[El Barto]

It's too bad no one really addressed my question. If you had ten sexual predators who each raped and killed their victim, if you could find a way to convince even one or two of them not to murder their victims while not putting them back on the street, would it be worth it?

Also, how could this be done?

Surely, it would make sense to keep a few more people alive. Thoughts?

[bernie]

[ QUOTE ]
Surely, it would make sense to keep a few more people alive. Thoughts

[/ QUOTE ]

What point would it be making to keep them alive yet still incarcerated forever? Cheap labor?

b

[El Barto]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
Surely, it would make sense to keep a few more people alive. Thoughts

[/ QUOTE ]

What point would it be making to keep them alive yet still incarcerated forever? Cheap labor?

b

[/ QUOTE ]

Boy, you completely muffed this one bernie. I'm talking about keeping the assault victims alive here, maybe a 7 year old girl who gets kidnapped. You seem to think I am talking about the kidnapper. Reread the post.

[bernie]

[ QUOTE ]
Boy, you completely muffed this one bernie.

[/ QUOTE ]

I sure did. [img]/images/graemlins/crazy.gif[/img]

I think for some kids, for what gets done to them, it's a lifelong sentence. In some cases, they don't ever recover from it.

I guess Im not sure what your point is. Are you asking if it's better just to be raped and not murdedered? You'd have to ask surviving victims. I'm sure some would agree with you. Some wouldn't.

I don't know how you think it would ever be possible to convince someone to rape a kid but not kill them by offering them, what?

Not sure what type of realistic answer you're looking for.

b