Starting Hand Selections - Varying Schools of Thought

I'm just putting it out there to see what you all think of this. What school of thought for starting hands do you find to be better? Sklansky's simplified approach from Small Stakes Hold Em or Hilger's more complicated approach from Internet Texas Hold Em. It seems that Hilger recommends being a little more tighter as well as having requirements for having a certain number of players enter the pot to play a number of hands. Thoughts?