Terribly frustrating problem with my dual monitor/laptop setup

[Karak567]

For some reason after I updated my video drivers (had some problems with them) I can only get 1680x1050 resolution (the resolution I use on my laptop) on "monitor 2" and can only get 1600x1200 on "monitor 1." Now if I make my laptop monitor 2, I can use 1680x1050 on it, however, it is then monitor 2 and everything goes to my 2001 FP. How can I fix this? AGHHH