Did Manning make any difference on the Colts team at all this season?

[Mano]

I was thinking about it, and with the team that the Colts had, I think pretty much any starting QB in the NFL would have gotten them to the second round of the playoffs, and could have scored at least as many points against the Pats. I think the MVP should be a difference maker (i.e. you should do better in the playoffs with the MVP than you would have if he were not on your team). Do you all agree?

[Shajen]

I dunno...but I will say this:

Vick was the MVP this year. We saw clearly how bad the Falcons were without him last year. THEY WERE BASICALLY THE SAME TEAM this year, with him in there, and now they are in the NFC championship game.

Enough said.

Manning does not perform well in big games. (His window is closing too)

[Daliman]

[ QUOTE ]
I dunno...but I will say this:

Vick was the MVP this year. We saw clearly how bad the Falcons were without him last year. THEY WERE BASICALLY THE SAME TEAM this year, with him in there, and now they are in the NFC championship game.

Enough said.

Manning does not perform well in big games. (His window is closing too)

[/ QUOTE ]

THe falcons quit early last year, and overachieved this year, simple as that. Michael VIck may be the most overrated QB in history.

Looks at the 1999 bears; 13-3 record, same team as year b4 and after, IIRC, and they didn't win 10 games total those 2 years.

[Victor]

[ QUOTE ]
THe falcons quit early last year, and overachieved this year, simple as that. Michael VIck may be the most overrated QB in history.


[/ QUOTE ]

This is bs.

You are clearly just racist against black quarterbacks. Go hang out with Rush.

[Lazymeatball]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
THe falcons quit early last year, and overachieved this year, simple as that. Michael VIck may be the most overrated QB in history.


[/ QUOTE ]

This is bs.

You are clearly just racist against black quarterbacks. Go hang out with Rush.

[/ QUOTE ]

Wow, you're an angry bigot, nice meeting you.

edit: unless there is some sort of sarcasm or joke here that I'm missing. Otherwise, see above.

[Daliman]

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
THe falcons quit early last year, and overachieved this year, simple as that. Michael VIck may be the most overrated QB in history.


[/ QUOTE ]

This is bs.

You are clearly just racist against black quarterbacks. Go hang out with Rush.

[/ QUOTE ]


LOL! Way to generalize.

My ranking of top NFL QB's
#1 Peyton Manning
#2 Daunte Culpepper
#3 Donovan McNabb


Also, my 1 y/o son has a Culpepper JErsey,and my favorite player is Randy Moss.

Go fuc<font color="black"></font>k yourself.

[daryn]

i think he was joking, donk. [img]/images/graemlins/laugh.gif[/img]

[sublime]

and my favorite player is Randy Moss.

are you serious?

[NoPeak]

[ QUOTE ]


THe falcons quit early last year, and overachieved this year, simple as that. Michael VIck may be the most overrated QB in history.

Looks at the 1999 bears; 13-3 record, same team as year b4 and after, IIRC, and they didn't win 10 games total those 2 years.

[/ QUOTE ]

I would have to agree, Vick is highly overrated as a QB. He is a great athlete, but indeed overrated as a QB.

[Shajen]

[ QUOTE ]

Looks at the 1999 bears...

[/ QUOTE ]

Hey, don't make this personal, damnit [img]/images/graemlins/grin.gif[/img]