[youtalkfunny]

I'd call the cops.

If he peed his pants when you confronted him, he'll absolutely fold under questioning.

Then you tell the cops that you'll drop the charges if he agrees to make restitution. GET THAT AGREEMENT IN WRITING.

What card was it?

EDIT: Calling the cops depends on the city in which you live. If the cops have their hands full with REAL crime, it may not be worthwhile. But if the cops in your town are bored (a good indicator of this is frequency of sitting around with the radar on), let them have a go at it.