Re: Good Question For Catholics and Others
[ QUOTE ]
whether you would believe a respected Pope who claimed he did a miracle given the feat could be duplicated
[/ QUOTE ]
Well, huff, "I've" been answering that in great detail [img]/images/graemlins/mad.gif[/img]
Believing him is not the same as 'did it happen as it appeared'. Here are some scenarios -
a) He's in on some trick.
b) He's not in on it, just a pawn in it.
c) It's not a trick, just a weird situation, Randi illustrated only one explanation for it.
the OPs original question -
[ QUOTE ]
After Randi's news conference how sure would you be, as a Catholic, that the Pope's astonishing feat was done without using an obvious trick?
[/ QUOTE ]
It's an excluded middle situaton. It's not two opposite posibilities - Pope pulling trick vs Divine. I'd temporarily assume a 'trick' by someone but I'd be open to some weird 'natural' cause also. There is nothing that would suggest the supernatural now, but there wasn't before Randi's suggestion either.
luckyme
|