Re: Civil War arguments
[ QUOTE ]
From a utilitarian point of view, it was in the Union's best interest to keep the south in the United States.
[/ QUOTE ]
Why?
[ QUOTE ]
I highly doubt that the United States would be as powerful as it is now if it had not preserved the union.
[/ QUOTE ]
Oh, okay... that's why. So you think that a powerful government is good for the utility of the people. For the moment, I will assume that interpersonal utility comparisions are feasible and that the concept of "ultilitarianism" has validity. You appear to be aware that the Civil War set the precedent for "big government." This means state forced involuntary servitude (conscription), an increase in coercive theft of property (taxes), and the many ineffecient government monopolies (run by bureaucracies). So you are telling me that society is better off because of these things? Death induced by slavery, extortion of funds, and the uniformity and inefficiency of government monopoly are REALLY good for society.
Now, given that it is a fact that interpersonal utility comparisions are not possible (humans are not homogenous)... imagine these things from the perspective of the individual?
|