[chezlaw]

[ QUOTE ]
The only logical problem I see has already been touched upon: the fact that you are assuming an absolute morality that both you and God are subject to, and can both appeal to. God could be subject to a completely different moral code than you are , in which case your moral code could quite rightly tell you that it is wrong, and God would still be good.

Also, there's the chance that all three of the possibilities you listed could be correct, as they are not mutually exclusive.


[/ QUOTE ]

I'm not making any assumption about an absolute morality for me. The only assumption for me is that I have moral feelings which I do.

It doesn't matter if all the possibilities are true as long as they can't all be false when the premise is true.

I'm not arguing against all religons (at least don't think so, but its possible I suppose) but my intention will become clear if we can agree on this simple logical argument (which seems in doubt at the moment [img]/images/graemlins/grin.gif[/img])

chez