Re: Two personal beliefs and their consequences
[ QUOTE ]
Yes he can. That would mean premise 3 is false. All four premises cannot logically be true at once:
[/ QUOTE ]
Obviously one of the premises has to be false. I'm saying premise 1 is false because fatalism is false.
If my fate was set at the big bang, why should it matter that the demon tells me what I am going to do. Fatalism holds that I must do what I am fated to do. It only matters if the demon cannot accurately predict the future. However fatalism(or determinism for that matter) says the demon must be able to predict the future. The reason fatalism falls down here is becuase of free will.
You people need to watch the Matrix trilogy again.
Stu
|