It sucks that D&D still carries such a heavy nerd stigma, but I think it's because you actually have to put a decent measure of mental effort into learning how to play and using your imagination.

Here's an actaul SAT analogy for all of you:
Pen and paper rpg is to PC rpg
as
sexual intercourse is to cybering.

BTW, you don't have to reroll initiative every round in 3rd ed. Did the players kill Meepo?