[Randy_Refeld]

[ QUOTE ]
villain disgustedly slams his hand face down on the felt. One card from villain's hand skips across the table and lands on top of the muck

[/ QUOTE ]

Describing a player throwing their hand into the muck is far different thatn a card merely touching the muck. If they truly kill hands for just touching the muck I would never play there because there is no way to know what other rules and procedures they don't understand until it happens.