I had similar results where I had far more 2nds and 3rds than 1sts. However, looking deeper into it I figured out that PT wasn't getting a lot of my 1st place summaries. Try going to Party and Affiliates tournament results-manual entry (assuming you play on Party)and scroll down through your existing tournaments. If there are tourneys where they show finishers 2-10 and your name isn't there, then you need to manual enter your name for first. Hope this helps.