No, I'd say they are more like this:
Me: This is what I did, what do you think?
People: I do this, bleh bleh bleh, etc.
Me: Ah, that's cool, but what about this?
People: Ah, true, *more discussion ensues*
Me struggling to understand what Soah is talking about isn't me calling him wrong, it's me wanting to understand what he is talking about because I am simply not getting it.
I realize it might look like I won't take anyone's opinion for a better answer, but that's simply not the case. I think it's due to this being every other post:
Person: Here's a hand, what do you think.
Reply: *anything*
Person: Ok, sounds good to me, I'll do that!
