From what you wrote sounds like he is your typical party $200NL fish right?

Pretty much, yeah.

If so I say pop-em, especially if your being as aggressive as your preflop raise leads me to believe. Fish pay off on far more occasions then they have the goods.

You don't think his check-raise is somewhat odd here? I really have no idea what his hand range could be, since I see this move so seldom.

Dumle