[sherbert]

OK. He's got a damn fine hand. I like MP3's reraise, as a lot of players will now put him on AA, leaving his hand very well disguised on the flop, although a reraise may have been more profitable with a suited or ds hand.
I'm less sure about your reraise here. However, it has the benefit, if that's the best word, of sorting everything out preflop. If the stacks are deeper on both sides, such a reraise becomes more dangerous and the comments of the other player, that you need AA for this reraise, would have been applicable - unless you had seen MP3 frequently reraise on less than stellar holdings.
For that matter, had MP3 decided that he had seen you raising a lot in EP on less than stellar hands? Again, that makes his reraise even more reasonable.
However, given the stack sizes involved - trivial - then only MP1 can be criticised. It wasn't Acesover8s after a day on the lash by any chance?
And there's not even a glimmer of a bad beat about how the hands played out.