[Pudge714]

[ QUOTE ]
Peyton is just in his own stratosphere in terms of production. Couple that with scouting, etc, and I think we can agree that Peyton isn't Peyton because of Harrison.

With Chad and Hines we can see their effects on other QBs. Maddox and Batch were horrible this year (and Maddox was horrible last year), so have a pretty decent idea that Roeth isn't just a product of the people around him. Kitna was off and on as the Bengals QB. Palmer was only above avrage last year with mostly the same people; I think Palmer represents either a true fluke or a step forward.

I dunno, am I making sense here? McNabb had pretty much set a level of performance and then TO came along and his performance spiked.

[/ QUOTE ]
I agree with what you said, however I guess I should have rephrased it how would every other QB do with James Thrash, Todd Pinkston, Torrance Small, and Fredex as there main targets, also keep in mind that before Westbrook he didn't have an above average rb. So I think he is somewhere in the middle, better than his pre TO stats, but worse than last years stats.