Thanks for all the input...

I've been trying to see where I've been going wrong..and it's big scary calls like this.

During the hand, I felt like it was probably right to call, but also seemed pretty risky because:

(a) The player knows I'm tight, and generally respects it
(b) I reraised his pot-size flop bet

Overall, I probably should have called here, just based on the LAG characteristics of the villain.

Another thought though:

What if this player was well known as a tight-player?
Is this still something I should be calling?