[HDPM]

It was the player who got in the muck. The dealer should be severly reprimanded for not protecting the muck. The player should be warned away from the other players. That should earn a suspension for the player IMO. What else was the guy doing in the muck and are we even sure the card he turned over was the one, ya know. When players are fishing in the muck you really DON'T KNOW for absolute sure that ace was there before, do you? He was probably just a superstitious rabbit hunting fool tho. Still.