View Single Post
  #1  
Old 11-14-2005, 04:10 AM
J Chap J Chap is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Durham, NC
Posts: 77
Default For Those Who Enjoy Meaningless Semantic Debates

Thank you in advance for being a nerd with me...

Here we go:

Flop is 3TJ rainbow. I have QK. I end up pushing all-in, and my opponent calls with AJ. No flush draws on the flop.

Given my correct inclination that I had 14 outs to the best hand, I was insulted by his insinuation that I got "lucky" when I won the hand. A polite altercation ensued.

He insisted that I needed to 'catch' in order to win. The way I see it, HE needed to catch cards-that-missed-me, which, in this case, were the minority. Basically, the fact that the first 5/7 of his Hold 'Em hand would make a higher-ranking Stud hand than mine is meaningless, since we were playing Hold 'Em. Right?

So, who, would you say, was "ahead" at the time?

Thank you for feeding my geekery.
Reply With Quote