My 24:

Mike Matusow
Phil Hellmuth
Phil Ivey
Greg Raymer
Marcel Luske
Howard Lederer
Annie Duke
Chip Reese
Freddy Deeb
Doyle Brunson
Daniel Negreanu
Erick Lindgren
Antonio Esfandiari
Johnny Chan
Dan Harrington
Scotty Nguyen
Joseph Hachem
Carlos Mortensen
John Juanda
Gus Hansen - Replaces Phil Laak on OP's list
Chris Ferguson - Replaces Paul Darden on OP's list
Jen Harman - Replaces Cyndy Violette on OP's list
Barry Greenstein - Replaces Paul Phillips on OP's list
TJ Cloutier - Replaces Layne Flack on OP's list.

That's the player-in-me's list. If I were a producer, I'd need Moneymaker on the show. Laak, Flack and Violette would be my alternates