Re: Borgata - Collusion?
The IWTSTH explanations in this thread seem to be the reasoning behind the commotion at the table - it's a rule that should be used only when suspected collusion is taking place, not as a "checking the hand history to see what they mucked" courtesy.
The only way I could see this as being collusion is if the 5/10 player thought players A and B were signalling to each other in some way regarding their hands, and player A wanted to see the hands that were being mucked to be sure the signals were correct. Extremely farfetched, but not beyond a Borgata regular.
|