I give it about a 3 on your rating system. The grim reaper type bad guy is quite visually scary and well done. The plot is ok, but I kinda put this on par with the Scream type movies, in that it isn't really a horror movie but more of a thriller. BTW, this movie owns Scream. I've seen it multiple times out of boredom when it comes on tv. It is a good way to kill some time and does in fact have a decent amount of rewatchability(Once a yearish).

Good Review Diebitter, I see I've missed a few, but thus far I've agreed with your reviews