[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
That ball clearly hit the dirt before he caught it.

I agree, you could just see the ball jump sharply up as it
went into the glove, so it must have hit the dirt.
Only after about 4 different replays did I notice that.

[/ QUOTE ]

I think that the ball bounced off the lether, the ball was caught. But it doesn't matter. The Umpire called him out. End of discussion.

[/ QUOTE ]

Yes, regardless of all this arguing, all Paul has to do is tag the guy to make certain he's out. Paul made a fundamental error, the ump was indecisive, AJ P made a heads up play and such is life.

2 outs, then a stolen base with 0-2 on Crede, and a ripped double down the line, come on. AJ P getting to first didnt lose this for them. They gave up a SB, then an 0-2 double raked down the line all with 2 outs.

Series tied, Buehrle pitched PHENOMENALLY and it should have been over anyway had Rowand just stayed at 3rd with nobody out! lol.