[Matt R.]

Maybe he just doesn't want to hear someone say that he's a bad player because his opinion differs. It is quite possible to give advice without being insulting.

And this decision is so close and so read dependent that going one way or the other would not automatically classify someone as a bad player.

Personally, I would call, and it IS due to stack size considerations. Hero is well below the average, but if he had a significant stack and losing here would bust him, I would fold. So, wiggs, I agree with your reasoning, and it's directly related to the math behind ICM. Therefore, you don't suck, at least based on your reasoning behind this play.