[greg nice]

the problem is that anyone who responds has no clue on how the villian plays. you have to use YOUR knowledge of the opponent to make decisions that are +ev. once you do that, you will see that posting a hand like this has no benefit, because no response you get will be as good as your live read.

did you play it fine? how do we know? you say he is 'tightish'. how tight? tight pre or post flop? how often will he fire 2nd barrel on turn with top pair medium kicker? how often will he fire a 3rd street?

should you raise the flop? fck if i know. will he call with worse hands? will he raise all in only when you are beat? whos gonna make the mistake on the flop or later streets if you raise?

i am not coming to any conclusions because i dont know the villian. i dont know how the villian perceives the hero. i dont know a lot of information thats needed to give a worthwhile opinion. these are the things you need to consider when playing the hand.