[McGahee]

I agree, sort of...
I mean, if you're serious about this game all you have to do is notice how newbs never have any reads and people like Enity & Nate tha' Great always have thorough breakdowns of their opponents - that ought to tell you something.
However, in terms of analyzing posts, I don't think there's anything detrimental in making people think about what the best line is to take against an unknown 1/2 villian - because the situations come up all the time where nobody stays at a table for more than 30 minutes.