[tiltaholic]

I'm putting my answer in white just because:
<font color="white">I don't think the statements are out and out contradictory.

I also think parts of statement 2 are incorrect.

Also, in these games, you can be making a +EV move that happens to be +EV for someone else too. So whether or not someone is correct to cold-call vs your 99 is almost irrelevant.
</font>