You wrote:
"if everyone who views this post "votes" for a number below then it should be the case that each number receives the same number of votes, roughly speaking"

Well, even assuming randomly picking the numbers, which will obviously not be the case, the number of votes will differ by "quite a bit".

You also wrote:

i predict that one particular number will stick out from the crowd like a sore thumb sticks out from a crowd of healthy thumbs.


Depending on the quantitive definition of the ol'sore thumb thing, you're not going too far out on a limb.