edgerrin james for torry holt? straight up trade
 

do you make this trade?
this would leave me with willis mcgahee, stephen davis, thomas jones and tatum bell at RB.

as for WR's, right now i have mccardell, jimmy smith, and amani toomer.

i think this is a good trade for me, anyone disagree?

Re: edgerrin james for torry holt? straight up trade
 

James is a much better player. You should be getting more for him.

Re: edgerrin james for torry holt? straight up trade
 

[ QUOTE ]
do you make this trade?
this would leave me with willis mcgahee, stephen davis, thomas jones and tatum bell at RB.

as for WR's, right now i have mccardell, jimmy smith, and amani toomer.

i think this is a good trade for me, anyone disagree?

[/ QUOTE ]

you can get a WR better than Holt for James I'd imagine

Re: edgerrin james for torry holt? straight up trade
 

Edge is a RB. Therefore, he's more valuable than Holt most of the time.

If you start 2 RB's and 3 WR's, I think you could make this trade, but you'd probably be asking for Moss or Owens instead. Otherwise, I'd reject it very, very quickly.

Re: edgerrin james for torry holt? straight up trade
 

Keep James. Trade Davis or Jones for Holt. Package somebody else with it if you have to.

Re: edgerrin james for torry holt? straight up trade
 

edge for holt straight is straight up retarded.

Re: edgerrin james for torry holt? straight up trade
 

It would improve your team, yes, but other posters are right: you can get much more for Edge.

Re: edgerrin james for torry holt? straight up trade
 

I'll dissent and say I'd do it.

Re: edgerrin james for torry holt? straight up trade
 

stay put, you have good depth. im not super confident and davis and jones

Re: edgerrin james for torry holt? straight up trade
 

[ QUOTE ]
Trade Davis or Jones for Holt. Package somebody else with it if you have to.

[/ QUOTE ]

Not happening.