MLB awards.. what about the ROY\'s?
 

Good discussion about the MVP and Cy Young awards, but how about the ROY's?

Re: MLB awards.. what about the ROY\'s?
 

street

francouer




i actually really dont know the specifics of everyone, thats my best guess.

Re: MLB awards.. what about the ROY\'s?
 

Duke would likely win ROY however the word is he will not qualify due to his recent injury, thus Francouer should win in a landslide.

Re: MLB awards.. what about the ROY\'s?
 

Cano should not even be in the discussion for ROY. He is so undeserving it is not even funny.

I give the AL ROY to Street and the NL ROY to Duke.

Re: MLB awards.. what about the ROY\'s?
 

and it's not even close

Re: MLB awards.. what about the ROY\'s?
 

He won't have enough starts.

Re: MLB awards.. what about the ROY\'s?
 

how many do you need?

queen felix wins it when the A's are playing golf in october.

Re: MLB awards.. what about the ROY\'s?
 

Iguchi:
.284 BA, 13 HR, 58 RBI, 14 SB, .352 OBP, .804 OPS

Re: MLB awards.. what about the ROY\'s?
 

[ QUOTE ]
Iguchi:
.284 BA, 13 HR, 58 RBI, 14 SB, .352 OBP, .804 OPS

[/ QUOTE ]

Isnt he over 30? I dont think Japanese players (or cuban, etc) who have been playing pro at the highest levels elsewhere for 10 years should be eligible. When Matsui won it I didnt think it was quite right. I think they should generally be in their first 1 or 2 pro seasons at the highest level. If someone is 32 but just broke through to the majors then they are a rookie. If theyve been playing at the highest level in japan, theyre not really rookies.

Re: MLB awards.. what about the ROY\'s?
 

Blanton. He has been great during the As fall run.