Plaxico or McCareins?
 

First week and out of my third WR spot I have to decide between Plaxico Burress or Justin McCareins. Plaxico faces the Cardinals with a Probably Manning and McCareins faces KC.

Re: Plaxico or McCareins?
 

Heimerdinger has to want to announce his presence with authority, demonstrating that he is indeed different than Mr. Hackett. I'd not be surprised with a very open offense, so I voted for Justin.

Re: Plaxico or McCareins?
 

I think Plax could have a big year. Has a big advantage of being able to pull down those jump-ball type throws in the end zone against just about anybody.

Re: Plaxico or McCareins?
 

i vote plax. has more upside but a bit more risky. pennington has said he is a big laverneus coles fan so he'll probably be the star of the jets wide receivers.

Re: Plaxico or McCareins?
 

I can see playing each other, thats why its a toss up for me. Arizona had the #9 passing defense last year whereas KC was last. Arizona gave up 18 TD's where KC gave up 32. If NYJ is behind in the game (which will probably be likely) they will be passing a lot at the end of the game.

In the long run I think Plaxico is the better pick, but for this game i think Justin might have the edge. Judging from the poll results its dead even.