Re: Donovan Mcnabb and the NAACP
 

no vick in the top 10. can always count on you for humor joa.

Re: Donovan Mcnabb and the NAACP
 

[ QUOTE ]
ROFL. And all the Bengals fans I know say Roethlisberger sucks

[/ QUOTE ]

im surprised by this bc ima bengals fan in ohio and all the bungles fans i know think rothlisberger is a very good and dangerous qb. they like bc he went to college right down the road.

Re: Donovan Mcnabb and the NAACP
 

[ QUOTE ]
no vick in the top 10. can always count on you for humor joa.

[/ QUOTE ]

ok, please look at the stats for aaron brooks and michael vick and tell me just how different they've been.

Re: Donovan Mcnabb and the NAACP
 

[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
no vick in the top 10. can always count on you for humor joa.

[/ QUOTE ]

ok, please look at the stats for aaron brooks and michael vick and tell me just how different they've been.

[/ QUOTE ]

oh sorry i forgot that passing stats are all that make up a qb. for some reason i must have overvalued actually winning football games.

Re: Donovan Mcnabb and the NAACP
 

You're right, going 7-4 against the easiest schedule in the NFL with a pretty good supporting cast is oh so very impressive.

Re: Donovan Mcnabb and the NAACP
 

[ QUOTE ]
Guys,

McNabb has never really had a great year except for last year. Obviously there's a huge disparity between last year and the years before in terms of WR Talent, but I'm skeptical. I think he's very similar to Kerry Collins.


[/ QUOTE ]

Whaat? Kerry Collins??

Re: Donovan Mcnabb and the NAACP
 

This article doesn't even deserve coment it is so absurd it should just be ignored. As far as top five QB's go I don't know how to rank them but McNabb is close if he is not in and how does Farve (I know he's just about done and the pack sucks but still) not even get mentioned?

Re: Donovan Mcnabb and the NAACP
 

Plummer & Bledsoe on the same level as McNabb? OK now I know you've been drinking.

Re: Donovan Mcnabb and the NAACP
 

Both of them were pretty average QBs their whole career until they got a top WR, and now they've suddenly found life.

Well, okay, my point was a lot stronger before Randy Moss was hurt but Collins was insane the first couple of weeks.

Re: Donovan Mcnabb and the NAACP
 

[ QUOTE ]
Plummer & Bledsoe on the same level as McNabb? OK now I know you've been drinking.

[/ QUOTE ]

Bledsoe's kind've tough to figure out. He had below average years his last two in Buffalo, but he's always been pretty good aside from that; certainly better than what McNabb always turned in pre-2004. As a Cowboy, he's returned to those levels.

Plummer's also a weird case. He's finally come around the last two years, but whether or not that has to do completely with Denver I'm not sure. Seeing as though Denver isnt' exactly a great pass-blocking team, I think we can say it isn't all Denver.